I like reddit as a forum; the non-linear conversation structure is the cat's meow. Although it could stand to gain the ability to opt-in to notifications on a post other than your own...

But I have one huge problem with reddit: the voting mechanic. It only invites appeals to popularity, hurts feelings and makes every disagreement confrontational.

Downvoting someone's post is inherently insulting. And I know this isn't just me because I've been accused of intolerance for downvoting people who disagree with me. This makes it almost impossible to keep disagreements civil because you can't express your disapproval of someone's post without them getting defensive, and quite understandably so. And even though you can't directly see when someone has downvoted you it's usually assumed if you're in a one-on-one conversation branch - bonus points for the occasional misunderstanding when someone else comes along and downvotes the person you're disagreeing with. And naturally it's even more insulting when you see invisible bystanding voters taking your opponent's side. Even if no one is explicitly invoking an appeal to popularity, it's still affecting how people feel.

Part of the problem is that each user's account keeps track of their total karma and so there's always this implicit quest to gain more karma. Being downvoted makes you feel like someone is trying to lower your "score" in what is not supposed to be a competition, but now is something worse, because if they're lowering yours and you're not lowering theirs then you have one-sided hostility, a tremendously powerful psychological effect. It makes every intellectual opponent an enemy.

I wish they would just hide the vote counts. It could still achieve the result of getting more liked posts to the top without any bad.

Some people might argue that visible vote counts can be useful to quickly gauge consensus, and that's a valid point, I'll admit. Especially when two people disagree on a matter of fact and neither one has transferrable proof this can be useful. But it's not worth how much it damages the culture and relationships and quality of discussion.


You don't need an account or anything to post. Accounts are only for email notifications on replies. Markdown formatting is supported.