Notes on operating systems I've tried

I've tried and researched a lot of Linux and BSD distributions in search of two goals:

  1. One to recommend to newcomers to Unix.

  2. One I'd want to use myself.

    I'm a software idealist - I don't want to use an operating system that isn't the best designed one. Where practicality and design quality conflict, I seek a balance, because I realize practicality is the point of it all, and I'm not an OS dev, but I want to support and encourage good architecture and also I think using it helps me grow wiser about software.

Here are my notes on the ones I've tried or researched and why I won't or will use them. When I say things like "broken install process", I mean that when I tried it, I ran into things that were clearly releng mistakes, such as the installer telling me to run a command that doesn't exist. I consider egregious instances of this pretty much disqualifiers; I don't want to use a distribution that's had problems like that, even if they've fixed it since.

Anything Debian-based (incl. Ubuntu, Mint)

Reputation: stable, user-friendly

Init system: systemd

Tried: Ubuntu years ago, Mint in 2020 summer


Reputation: fork of Debian that switches out systemd for sysvinit. Everything else from Debian applies.

Tried: 2020 summer


Reputation: cutting-edge

Init system: systemd

Tried: 2020 summer (only on server)

CentOS is derived from Fedora (through Red Hat), so it's much the same except its packages are outdated as hell.


Reputation: DIY for advanced users

Init system: systemd


Reputation: Linux/BSD hybrid

Init system: runit

Tried: 2020 summer, multiple times.


Reputation: DIY for advanced users, nightmarish install process

Init system: OpenRC (others supported)

Tried: years ago (mentor helped with install); no first-hand recent experience.


Init system: sysvinit


Tried: 2020-09-17

Reputation: secure, lightweight

Init system: OpenRC


Tried: 2020 summer - present.

Reputation: Arch without systemd.

Init system: choice of OpenRC, runit or s6. I use OpenRC.


Tried: unknown year - 2020 summer.

Reputation: the go-to BSD.

Init system: BSD init

Init systems

I keep referencing these and as you can see, systemd is a disqualifier at least for my own use. I explain this now.


I don't have much personal experience with systemd. My negativity from it pretty much comes from hearsay, but well-sourced hearsay. Two in particular:

BSD init

Works well enough, but service files are extremely cumbersome.


Colored output. Service files are concise.


Runit has fewer lines of code than OpenRC, which attracts me, and I also like the way it leverages the filesystem instead of reinventing it. For example, services are "enabled" by symlinking them into a certain directory.

I like a lot of things about runit, but there are two issues I have, might be solvable but I don't know how:


Legacy standard. I don't know much about it, but the prevailing opinion seems negative.

A few other things I explain about the connection between my notes and my judgements:

This page was last modified 2022-01-03 16:57 (UTC).


Subscribe via RSS feed:

This site doesn't host comments because that would be against my principles: discussion belongs in a dedicated, decentralized medium like Lemmy (tag me if you start one!).